Re: Qualifying Final: Centrals v West - Sunday 16 September, 3:10pm @ AAMI Stadium

by bloodsasia Mon Sep 17, 2012 6:01 pm

Shame about Hartlett, has had so many setbacks in his career with injury and now may have put himself out of a final, if he challenges and loses he may miss a Grand Final so I cant see them taking it on.

Well done to the Bloods, terrific win. Listened to the entire game in China through Life FM, not a single problem with the feed - Great work LIFE FM!!

A great reward for the die hard West fans who stuck with the club through a very tough few years (you know who you are). Now lets do it all again next week.

by waddayamean Mon Sep 17, 2012 8:57 pm

Big Phil wrote:Tom has had a good season for the Dogs, including being selected for State Representation. He has had his issues with a hip complaint all year that has limited his training at times but overall I think he has had a good year.

Quite clearly he had his colours lowered yesterday by Brad Fisher, specifically in the second half, but I think he has been a good recruit. I would have liked to see him tried as a forward at times throughout the year but that didn't eventuate.

Don't underestimate the quality of footballer that Brad Fisher is. I'm not sure any defender would have stopped him in that second half yesterday. Tom will bounce back this week, especially if he gets more opportunities to run off his opponent and create drive from defence, which has been one of his strong points this year.

What are you thoughts on Tom, waddyamean? Also, what are thoughts on Sturt defender come forward James McLeay? I think he and Collier are similar players.

I think Collier is a good player ,I was surprised to read the comments in MMCM about him.I could him forward as well.

by waddayamean Mon Sep 17, 2012 9:03 pm

Big Phil wrote:
brodlach wrote:Looks like both Gowans got off for their little jabs too
The twins are angels and never do anything wrong - just ask waddyamean

I would have thought this quote should be reversed Phil . Surely you will defend them Very Happy

Little jabs , no surely not . I would have thought they stand faceto face to the bloke ? Tough blokes do that I suppose.

by eartotheground Tue Sep 18, 2012 1:27 pm

Media members who also hold roles at clubs - as indicated elsewhere regarding match day positions - need to take cautiion in being seen as being too proactive in highlighting incidents prior to them being officially cited.

by Sponsored content