SANFL Grand Final Umpires 2012

eartotheground wrote:A few people around the SANFL watching with interest that a media identity is getting involved in this sort of thing.

What sort of thing, ettg?
Posting on a footy forum?

i'll bet there is more than the 3 media celebrities we know that post, but we don't know their identity (not that we should know or have to know anyway), while it is easy to take pot shots at people i don't see what benefit anyone gets from it, surely everyone & anyone is interested in footy & that's the bottom line imho

Ditto.

Celebrities ? Serious ? You mean like Dennis Commetti ,Sam Newman, KG , the list goes on. Easy . I think Phil posting is fine, as with all posters we all disagree at times .
I admit I don't like posters playing games though and working forums.

I also think this site is a bit too quick at times to jump on little things.

To grow the site will need to allow a bit of controversy .Not outright stupidity and posters just posting nothing about football like SA Footy. A bit of disagreeing hurts no one and is good to create debate.


Yes some are a bit sensitive though.

eartotheground wrote:A few people around the SANFL watching with interest that a media identity is getting involved in this sort of thing.

waddyamean is a media identity?

how about 'media identities' then ?

agree with most of that post

Good helpful post, Waddayamean.

The good thing about this site is that we've hardly had to delete a post at all. Perhaps we might be a bit quick with a gentle reminder here or there, but we feel that's better than deleting posts and posters have been really good in accepting that and moving on.

i thought the umpires were very good on Grand Final day

bayman wrote:i thought the umpires were very good on Grand Final day

Agreed. DeBoy has improved out of sight, IMHO...

Probably only 1 very technical 'no feel for the game' call with a 25m penalty paid late in the day...